North Idaho Republican Staff
A Boise daycare and three parents have appealed the dismissal of their lawsuit challenging Idaho’s Medical Freedom Act. The appeal is before the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
The plaintiffs, Le Soleil Child Care LLC and the parents, argued that the 2025 law is unconstitutionally vague. The statute bars businesses, governments and schools from requiring vaccines or other “medical interventions,” including procedures, treatments, devices, drug injections, medications and other medical actions.
Chief U.S. District Judge Amanda K. Brailsford dismissed the case in September after granting Idaho Attorney General Raúl Labrador’s request. Brailsford ruled that the law gives people fair notice of the conduct it prohibits.
“The (Idaho Medical Freedom Act) plainly and unambiguously sets out a standard of prohibited conduct that gives a person of ordinary intelligence fair notice of what is prohibited,” Brailsford wrote.
The plaintiffs filed their appeal late last month. An attorney representing them declined to comment. Labrador’s office could not be reached immediately for comment.
Idaho Gov. Brad Little vetoed an earlier version of the legislation. A spokesperson for Little said in April that the revised law does not stop public schools or daycares from sending home children who are sick. A Senate effort to override the veto failed.
Leslie Manookian has said she wants Idaho’s law to serve as a national model for similar measures.